9 Sols Parry System Breakdown
Introduction
In this design breakdown, I’ll analyze the Parry system in 9 Sols to understand the design decisions behind it, what those decisions are and why they might have been made.
In 9 Sols there is a very unique parry system, while a lot of other games have a simple timed button pressed to parry, 9 sols have a much more expressive and deep system, splitting the parry to 3 types, normal, air and charge, with an additional imperfect parry that can happen in case of a small timing error, each of those has its own advantages and disadvantages:
-
Normal Parry: the normal parry is the most basic parry in the game it is performed with a simple button press while on the ground, to successfully parry the attack must be a normal type attack and the character must face the attack, and the button press has to be in a very small time frame of the attack hitting the player, the parry completely negating the damage.
-
Air Parry (tai-chi kick): it is performed with a simple button press while airborne, the character doesn't have to face the enemy and it can counter both normal the green type attacks, performing it on some of the attacks can result in a short stun animation in addition to negating the damage.
-
Charged Parry (Unbounded Counter): is performed by holding the parry button for at least 0.5s before releasing it, the character doesn't have to face the enemy and it can counter all attack types, performing it on some of the attacks can result in a short stun animation in addition to negating the damage.
-
Imperfect Parry: is the result of messing the timing of a normal or air parry, it results in the player receiving 50% of the attack damage as “internal damage” (damage the is not applied instantly and cant kill you) it also add hit stop 0f 0.6s to the player preventing them to do anything in that time.
The following table show some of the differences between the parries:
As you can see from the table each of the parries is very distinct which adds a lot of depth to the system, the system also feeds into the talisman system (which we will not go over here) by giving the player energy charges.
I consider 9 Sols's parry system a brilliant piece of design for the following reasons:
-
It makes every enemy feel fresh:
The system is almost impossible to completely master, every new enemy and especially bosses require the player to re-learn the animations, parry timings and types in order to truly master it, so even a really skilled player and a learning curve when encountering a new enemy. -
It is simple yet deep:
While the combinations of the different enemies and parries create a system that is very deep and unique the designers kept it simple by keeping it all to a 1 button press, allowing players to focus on timing and matching the parries rather than input complexity. -
The system is OP:
While it is hard to master, after mastering it the system allows the combat to look effortless, negating all the incoming attacks in what feels almost like a rhythm game and a dance. -
It resonate with the game story and theme:
The whole game story and theme is around the Chinese philosophy of Taoism, more specifically the concept of Wu Wei of non-action, which is talking about natural action without access effort, having the character having to be still and mainly parrying instead of frantically moving around trying to avoid the attacks is a masterful reflection of that.
Risks and Rewards
As with basically all parry systems here too it is all about risk and rewards, but here the system is designed to be overturned in favor of the rewards to encourage using the system and the main form of defense, let's list the risks and rewards.
Risks:
-
Missing the timing results in 50% damage as internal damage and hit stun for 0.5s
-
Missing the timing completely results in 100% damage and sometimes knock back and knock down
-
Spamming the parry button increase the timing window to 0.1 on second press and completely remove it after that
-
It requires you to stand still instead of trying to avoid the hit, in case of jump parry you need to actively sic the hit box
-
For charge parry you have to stand in place for at least 0.5 seconds (though it can be canceled into a dodge)
Rewards:
-
Complete cancelation of damage
-
Only 50% internal damage in imperfect parry which cant kill you and can be restored
-
Create an opening to counter attacks
-
In some cases knocking out the enemies giving even longer time to counter attack
-
Give 1-2 charges for using talisman attacks which is much more powerful than normal attacks
-
Disable shields on some enemies
-
Deal internal damage to enemies
-
Redirect projectiles back at enemies
-
Charged parry can block multiple attack within a short time frame
As you can see there are much more rewards than risks in this system, and even the risks themselves have some ways to make them less risky like the more lenient timing for imperfect parry and the ability to cancel charged parry into a dodge.
Though the risks are still not something to take lightly and the parry is still hard to master, those rewards highly incentivize the player to use the parry as their main form of defense and making mastering it so satisfying and fun.
Interaction with other game systems
The Parry is a very integral part of the whole game, as such multiple systems interact and designed around it:
-
Skill tree: allow to upgrade the parry effects and unlock them gradually during the game
-
Talisman system: the parry is the only way to gain energy charges to perform the talismans attacks
-
Dash: the dash is the 2nd option for the player to avoid damage, it has a 1s cooldown after using making it much harder to use repeatedly, again incentivizing more the use of the parry
-
Enemy design: While in other games enemies are a lot more “fair” here even the basic enemies have very big hitboxes that sometimes exceed the visual animation which make trying to maneuver around the attacks much harder and less intuitive, pushing the player to use and master the parry as their main defense option.
Risk of System Failure
Though the system is very carefully designed, as with a lot of hard “souls like” games it is very risky, it requires the players to get a handle of the parries very early on in the game, from the very first enemies that are hard to get through without parrying, to the first boss that act as the first wall that require the player to get a get handle of the parry to pass.
All of those are very intentional to push the player to play in a specific way but it might also push away players who are not good at it or that are not connected with this play style. Though to mitigate it and allow more players to enjoy the game, it offers a “story mode” which allows players to adjust difficulty for easier experience.
Design Intent Hypothesis
-
3 Parry types: creates variety, depth and a higher skill ceiling, while keeping the system simple, making the game challenging and engaging from start to finish, each parry has its advantages and disadvantages pushing the player to use them in a smart way trying to understand what is the right fit to any situation.
-
Imperfect parry and charge cancel: reducing the risk of parries, incentivising the player to use the system more.
-
OP rewards for parries: further incentivising the use of parries and creating high satisfaction on success.
-
“Unfair” enemy designs: big hitboxes for enemies disincentivising trying to maneuver around the attacks and further pushing to use parries
-
Unlocking/Upgrading through the skill tree: gradually introducing the different parries and effects, creating a smoother learning curve and good sense of progression.
Conclusion
The 9 Sols Parry system is very unique and an integral part of the combat system, arguably it is the main reason the game feels so fun and satisfying to play. By overturning the rewards the designers heavily incentivise the player to use it while at the same time making it very satisfying and fun to use, while skill keeping it challenging with a high skill ceiling. The designers also designed a lot of the other game systems and enemies around it to accommodate the overpowered nature of it to keep the game challenging and further incentivising its use.
Finally the designers emphasized the system not just for its engagement value on the gameplay side, but also to fit the game themes of Taoism and non-action creating a system that requires much more static patience and concentration which can even put you in a zen-like flow state.
For all those reasons I think this system is masterfully designed and is making the combat system one of the most fun I have ever played.
