Deep Dive: How Interactivity Redefines Storytelling.
Introduction
In this day and age the case has already been made for “are video games art?”, however though most people will concede the idea that video games are indeed art, many individuals still view video games as a lesser form of art that lacks the same impact that other art forms have.
In this essay, I would like to explain and demonstrate why video games are not just art but one of the most powerful storytelling devices. I would try to do that by using my personal favorite game Undertale, exploring how it uses the strength of the medium to make a great impact on the player and reveal their own inner nature.
Why Video Games
Video games are the newest medium of storytelling, still in its baby stages, we are probably only scratching the surface of the narrative capabilities of video games.
stories have been told throughout all of human history as a means to entertain, teach, preserve culture, and a lot more, but most importantly they explore human nature and psyche, helping us understand ourselves and the world around us better.
First in the most basic verbal form, then came paintings and text helping to create deeper stories that can be preserved and passed on, the next big revolution in storytelling came with movies and the ability to visualize stories with moving images, voices, and music adding layers to the story experience though not fundamentally changing it as it mostly moved the images from the mind of the reader onto the screen.
on the other side, there are games, which in some shape or form also existed throughout history, first in the more primal forms of hunting simulations like tag and hide and seek, but then with more complex pretend play of mother and father and similar simulations, even from those early forms games have already started to toy with storytelling but I do say didn't really have the structured storytelling capacity that traditional stories had, letter on board games introduces basic stories into gameplay, one of the oldest examples is what we know today as Snakes and Ladders, originally created in India to represent the concept of fate and the karmic cycle, very deep and meaningful but still very basic in its form.
The next revolution came from tabletop role-playing games, combining a storyteller (the dungeon master) with a structured rule set to create grand narrative experiences where there is a very dynamic interaction between the storyteller and the players creating stories on the go. but here still there is a problem, the problem is that the story is too dynamic making it hard to pass the same story to different players, sometimes the player's actions might not fit at all with the storyteller's intention making it hard to craft structured stories with meaningful arcs and philosophical conflicts.
Enter video games, starting with very basic gameplay and very basic stories if at all similar to board games but with recent years development video games have become a place where grand narratives can be crafted, with visuals matching those of movies, though more limited than tabletop role-playing games, video games can still give players interactivity choices and room to impact the story while the storyteller is much more in control in what the player can or can't do allowing the storyteller to create the story they want to tell with structure, themes, and conflicts, making it, in my opinion, the next evolution in storytelling.
With Video games, the storyteller can create a very linear story with very few ways to change it or an open sandbox where the player can do whatever they like with the tools they are given, in any case, the storyteller is the one in control and the amount of freedom the player has is always in their hands, if the player can jump it must be programmed into the game and something the whole game has to account for if the player can kill a character than that option too must have been programmed into the game and accounted for, in most cases the player cant act in a way that is not pre-planned for and there far will go against the creator intentions.
Then why is interactivity in stories so important? Interactivity allows the player to participate in the story instead of experiencing it as an observer, in a conventional story the reader will follow the story and its character and try to put themselves in the character's shoes, in video games the player is in the character shoes in a real sense, making the choices with/for them.
Then why are choices important? In any story, the choices a character makes tell us about who the character is, and what his/her values, philosophies, priorities, strengths, and weaknesses are, a character might tell the player all of those things, but characters are not always completely honest, the choices they make will show their true self as actions speak louder than words. The same happens when the player makes the choices, it allows the player to explore themselves, and what they believe. What is important to them? Letting the player make choices in scenarios that they will probably never encounter and will not have the opportunity to explore in real life.
But though choices are important, they need to be or at least feel meaningful, and the things that make a choice meaningful are consequences, if a choice doesn't change anything then why choose at all? You can just leave it to chance and it will not change a thing, so we have to have consequences for our choices to feel meaningful.
The Problem With Video Games
The first problem is “The Magic Circle”: the problem with choices in most video games is that it is easy for the player to separate themselves from the choices they made in the game, that is the concept that is called the magic circle, “In the context of games, the magic circle is the area within which the rules of the game apply, a special space, ideally but not necessarily demarcated by the rules within which play occurs”. The magic circle is a safe mental space that allows players to separate themselves from what happens in the game world. After all, they are role-playing, just playing a character and the character is the one doing the choices.
So in a traditional story, the choice a character makes is very real for the character in that story, so we can relate to that and learn about the character, but when it comes to a player making a choice in a video game, the choice isn't as real and it is easier for them to separate themselves from the choice, that way the player can kill hundreds of people in a game like GTA without feeling a full psychological wight of murder, this usually helps keep the game fun but also makes it harder to make the player consider their choices and give them weight and meaning.
The 2nd problem is Consequences: consequences are an aspect that video games struggle with, the first reason is that video games content is expensive to make, creating visuals, animations, dialogs, and so on for every choice the player makes is basically impossible, which is why most games either focus on short term consequences that doesn't impact much the overall story, or on a few (2-3) paths that are usually very obvious and linear (good, bad and neutral).
The second reason is that as a video game, the consequences possible are very limited, the worst most games can do is give the player a “bad ending” and even with that the player can always rest and try another path, making the choices feel much less important.
So we have 2 pretty big problems when trying to create meaningful choices in video games, now let's talk about Undertale and see how it uses the medium strength to create one of the most meaningful choices I ever encountered in a video game.
What is Undertale?
Undertale is a small indie game, crowd-funded for only 50K$ and developed mostly by a single guy named Toby Fox, the game is relatively very short with around 6 hours of playtime, the visuals are very basic, some might describe them as even ugly at times.
Undertale sells itself as a game where "no one has to die" the game's main selling point is its combat system which allows the player in every combat encounter to talk to the monsters instead of fighting them and eventually sparing them, the game also features a lot of 4th wall breaking points where the game is directly commenting on or referencing the player or common video game conventions and tropes.
the game features a blank slate kid character who falls into the underground where the monsters were banished, on the way through the game to find the exit back to the human world the player encounters different monsters which the player will come to know, understand and even befriend if chosen the non-violent root, eventually realizing that the monsters are mostly friendly and at the end freeing the monsters from their underground prison.
Undertale use of Choice
The main choice in Undertale is whatever the player decides to kill or spare a monster in any given encounter theoretically giving the player countless number of choices, though as video games are limited there are only 3 different endings to the game:
-
neutral: where the player kills some monsters and spares the others,
-
pacifist: where the player doesn't kill any monster
-
genocide: where the player decides to kill every single monster
and so though the player seemingly has countless choices (which the game goes to great length to make every one of those feel important) the game really has only 3 choices between the 3 different endings.
but that would be false too because as the player first plays the game assuming they play it without prior knowledge they will most likely get themselves locked into the neutral ending, as both the pacifist and genocide run has some particular steps that should be taken in order to get them and the game heavily push the player to play in the right order, neutral, pacifist, genocide, and it would require research before playing to break this order.
So does that mean that the player has no choice in this game at all? Is it only the illusion of choice that had such an impact? We will go over the player's journey through the game and see how the game actually offers the player one choice but it is (in my opinion) the most real and meaningful choice I ever experienced in a game, which cuts deep into the player's psychology and nature.
The Neutral Run:
As the player starts the game for the first time they will be introduced to the game sparing system which allows the player to speak/act to the monsters instead of fighting them each requiring the player to meet certain conditions to be able to spare the monster, usually requiring the player to understand the monster character to meet the condition. In the first playthrough of the game even if the player decided they don't want to kill the game will trick the player into killing some of the monsters by accident, locking them into the neutral path.
Through the neutral run the player will come to know the world and characters of the game, this path, though light-hearted, is bittersweet, as the player comes to know the tragedy of the monsters locked in the underground. In the end, the player escapes the underground alone leaving all the characters they came to know and probably love behind to stay in their underground prison.
The end also gives the player a clue to the pacifist run, when the game antagonist (which is 4th wall breaking aware of the player's ability to replay the game) tells the player that they can get a better ending by not killing anyone and most importantly befriending them.
The Pacifist Run
and so the player restarts the game, this time armed with new knowledge and determined not to kill any monster so they can get the better ending, and this is probably the most fun run of the game, it is mostly more cheerful and fun, the player even ends up dating the monsters which give you more in-depth information and characterization. The player finds out more about the lore of the world, even though most story bits along the way are the same.
By the end of the run, all of the monsters in the underground that the player went out of their way to spare and befriend come to the player's aid to defeat the antagonist, but then instead of killing the antagonist, the player ends up saving and sparing it too, resulting in the antagonist using its power the break the barrier that seals the monsters underground and setting them free. This is the best ending the player could wish for. It is wholesome and heartwarming and cheerful, this path and ending are really setting in the player the feeling they care about this world and those characters and even feel like they made friends with them.
But then at the very end, the antagonist evil form appears again, breaking the 4th wall to talk directly to the player, this time to beg the player not to restart the game as they are the only ones who have the power to ruin this good ending, quote:
"There is one thing, one last threat, one being with the power to erase EVERYTHING... that is right I am talking about YOU, YOU have the power to reset everything... If you so choose, everyone will be ripped from this timeline... so please just let them go, let them be happy, let them live their lives"
what this does to the player are 2 very important things:
-
Establishing the fact that the player itself is an entity in the game and what they do to the game world by saving, loading, and restarting are canon to the game world and story creating different timelines, adding much more weight to everything the player does.
-
Together with the player's knowledge about other games that offer "good" and "bad" paths, implanting curiosity in the player's mind, the idea of "what happens if I reset but this time will kill everyone instead".
and here is where the player faces the choice, in my opinion probably the realest choice a player had to face in a video game, stop now and be satisfied with the good ending, or see what will happen if you kill everyone.
The twisted thing is, that the more the player love this world and the character in it the more they will want more content, more information, more game, and the more they will be tempted to destroy everything they love in the game with the excuse that "well it is just a game, I can always reset and get the good ending again" but this game is different than games they played in the past.
The Genocide Run
This run is a bit different and requires a bit of digging through the internet to know how to trigger it, as it doesn't just require the player to kill everything they encounter but to actively hunt down every monster until the very last one, that is why it was given the unofficial name of "Genocide" by the community.
And so the player starts running around looking for every monster, an act that is usually pretty normal in other games and is called "grinding", usually done to get the player character stronger to pass more easily the next game obstacles. here is given a more sinister context, this run is the darkest most disturbing path, the cheerful music that was played in previous playthroughs is now slowed down to create an eerie white noise, the once lively towns are now empty as everyone is running away and hiding from YOU, but most importantly it is not fun, it is tedious and takes forever, and it is by design, like the creator of the game didn't even want you to do it, like it tries to encourage you to give up and just stop, but you won't, you need to know more and you get what you want, this rout revile some very interesting details about the world and characters by how they react to the evil force that is now YOU.
Through this route, there are a lot of interesting story bits and I want to highlight the 3 most important ones that come in the form of 3 encounters each drilling down the severity of the player's action, trying to make them stop. those come in the form of the true hero, the judge, and the monster:
The True Hero:
Undyne, in the normal playthrough, is the royal guard who hates humans and hunts down the player character as a form of misguided justice, in this run though she dies in just one hit when protecting a kid that the player was about to kill, then while realizing that she is the only one that can stop you she is reborn as the "true hero" giving the player one of the hardest fights in the game so far, and as the game declare her as the true hero, it marks you as the true villain and true evil, emphasizing it with Undyne's monolog:
"This isn't just about monsters anymore, is it? If you get past me, you'll... You'll destroy them all, won't you? Monsters... Humans... Everyone... Everyone's hopes Everyone's dreams. Vanquished in an instant.
But I WON'T let you do that. Right now, everyone in the world... I can feel their hearts beating as one. And we all have ONE goal. To defeat YOU.
Human, No, WHATEVER you are. For the sake of the whole world... I, UNDYNE, will strike you down!"
The Judge:
Sans, is mostly the comedic and "Jester" character, he actually will never fight the player in the other paths, but will always confront them just before the end, compelling them to reflect on their path. But here Sans reveals his true nature, he can't let himself sit aside and watch anymore, as he is the only character other than the antagonist that has knowledge of the game's nature and the different timelines. Sans further emphasize the severity of the player's action, as he, that was once a neutral force, now forced to step in in intervene, while also suggesting that if the player continues there will be no going back:
"Our reports showed a massive anomaly in the time-space continuum.
Timelines jumping left and right, stopping and starting...
Until suddenly, everything ends.
Seeing what comes next...
I can't afford not to care anymore."
San is also aware of the player's motivation analyzing them psychologically and even trying to appeal to their past memories together, to make the player give up:
"There's a glimmer of a good person inside of you. The memory of someone who once wanted to do the right thing. Someone who, in another time, might have even been... A friend? Do you remember me? Let's forget all this, ok? Just lay down your weapon...
I know your type. You're very determined, aren't you?
You'll never give up, even if there's absolutely NO benefit to persevering whatsoever. No matter what, you'll just keep going. Not out of any desire for good or evil... But just because you think you can, and because you "can", you "have to". But now, you've reached the end. There is nothing left for you now. So in my personal opinion the most "determined" thing you can do here? is to completely give up."
And lastly sans is an extreme difficulty spike in the game and the last boss trying to stop the player from proceeding in this path.
The Monster:
Flowey is the antagonist who taunted you all along in the normal paths and was always the final fight of the game, here he is also the final encounter but is the complete opposite of Sans, as Sans never fights you except here, Flowey always fights you except for here. Flowey is a pathetic, nihilistic, and miserable character all along the game, and here he reveals his story of why he became like that, and also reveals to the player that he is exactly like them:
"Then I woke up like it was all just a bad dream. I was back at the garden, back at my "save point". Interested, I decided to experiment...
At first, I used my powers for good, I became "friends" with everyone, I solved all their problems flawlessly, their companionship was amusing... For a while. As time repeated, people proved themselves predictable. What would this person say if I gave them this? What would they do if I said this to them? Once you know the answer, that's it, that's all they are.
It all started because I was curious, curious what would happen if I killed them. "I don't like this." I told myself, "I'm just doing this because I HAVE to know what happens. Ha ha ha... What an excuse, you of all people must know how liberating it is to act this way.”
Flowey even references and criticizes those who chose not to do it but still decided to consume it through videos on the internet:
"At least we're better than those sickos that stand around and WATCH it happen... Those pathetic people that want to see it. But they are too weak to do it themselves."
By revealing this to the player the game creates a direct comparison between the player and the antagonist, both hitting the final nail in placing the player as the true villain of the game and suggesting to the player what this kind of path might lead them to.
After that Flowey starts to try and convince the player that they are on the same side begging them not to kill him:
"I'm helpful, I can be useful to you. I promise I won't get in your way. I can help... I can... I can...
Please don't kill me."
Here the player will press the attack button one last time and will kill Flowey, the last character, it is also the last chance for the player to exit and restart, but it is probably too late.
after killing Flowey a demon child with glowing red eyes appear, a dark reflection of the player's character, but also of the player themselves, thanking the player for awaking them by doing the genocide run, with every monster killed giving it power, the demon child proceeds to "erase the world" crushing and closing the game. The next time the player tries to open the game only a black screen will wait for them and the sound of blowing wind, nothing is left to play, the player has destroyed the game world and it can't be played again, there will not be another chance for a happy ending.
Conclusion
Let's return to the problems we mentioned before, and see how Undertale deal with them
The Magic Circle:
While most choices in Undertale can be shrugged off using the magic circle, by breaking the 4th wall Undertale takes you out of the circle, it is not your character that decided to rest the game it is YOU only you can do it as the player, and this choice is canonical to the story, and in addition to that even after you made your choice the game keeps pushing against you trying to get you to turn back and stop playing, so the player has to keep making the choice to continue in that path again and again.
And with that, the player doesn't have many excuses but to face the fact that it is they who made the choices, which also makes the next point hit much harder.
Consequences:
Undertale is a small simple game, most of the game's story is told through very simple visuals and text which are relatively cheap to create, that way, creating countless variations within the neutral run. Those are minor and less significant, but still, give the feeling of realness to the smaller choices.
Then there are the big ones, the pacifist and genocide paths and endings making significant changes to the game content even though the main path is still mostly linear and stays the same.
But most interesting is the ultimate consequence at the end of the genocide run, where the player had the biggest choice, they faced the biggest consequence. The player loses the option to get a good ending, which is much different than just getting a bad ending, in contrast to all other games here after the bad ending there is no way to go back and get a good ending again, the game was changed forever as a consequence of the player choice and as far as I know is the harshest consequence a video game can give to the player.
So to conclude video games give power to storytellers, to tell interactive stories where on one hand they have high control over the story and where it goes, and on the other hand still allow players room for interactions, choices, and exploration, creating meaningful and interesting experiences that may have a great impact on the ones experiencing it, and this, for me at least, is the power of video games.














